| Captain |
Tenure |
| Ryan Callahan |
Sept. 12, 2011 to present |
| Chris Drury |
Oct. 3, 2008 to June 29, 2011 |
| Jaromir Jagr |
Oct. 5, 2006 to May 4, 2008 |
| Mark Messier |
Jul. 13, 2000 to Apr. 3, 2004 |
| Brian Leetch |
Oct. 3, 1997 to July 12, 2000 |
| Mark Messier |
Oct. 7, 1991 to May 25, 1997 |
| Kelly Kisio |
Dec. 24, 1987 to May 30, 1991 |
| Ron Greschner |
Oct. 9, 1986 to Dec. 3, 1987 |
| Barry Beck |
Feb. 4, 1981 to May 9, 1986 |
| Walt Tkaczuk |
Dec. 7, 1980 to Feb. 3, 1981 |
| Dave Maloney |
Oct. 11, 1978 to Dec. 6, 1980 |
| Phil Esposito |
Nov. 12, 1975 to Oct. 10, 1978 |
| Brad Park |
1974-75 to Nov. 7, 1975 |
| Vic Hadfield |
1971-72 thru 1973-74 |
| Bob Nevin |
Feb. 5, 1965 thru 1970-71 |
| Camille Henry |
Feb. 23, 1964 to Feb. 4, 1965 |
| Andy Bathgate |
1961-62 to Feb. 22, 1964 |
| George Sullivan |
1957-58 thru 1960-61 |
| Harry Howell |
1955-56 thru 1956-57 |
| Don Raleigh |
Nov. 4, 1953 thru 1954-55 |
| Allan Stanley |
Dec. 20, 1951 to Nov. 3, 1953 |
| Frank Eddolls |
1950-51 to Dec. 6, 1951 |
| Buddy O'Connor |
1949-50 |
| Neil Colville |
1945-46 thru Dec. 21, 1948 |
| Ott Heller |
1942-43 thru 1944-45 |
| Art Coulter |
1937-38 thru 1941-42 |
| Bill Cook |
1926-27 thru 1936-37 |
|
Barry Beck
Brian Leetch
Phil Esposito
Bill Cook
Mark Messier |
